Piracy Update, 20 November, 2011

Somalia/Gulf of Aden/Indian Ocean:

NATO Reports show at least three attacks and at least three incidents of vessels being approached in a suspicious manner by skiffs that appeared to be pirates, but there were no successful attacks reported.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/3/33/INS_Suvarna.jpg/1024px-INS_Suvarna.jpgINS Suvarna, sister ship of INS Sukanya. Photo: INS SuvarnaM. Mazumdar/ Bharat-Rakshak. Original uploader was Mittal.fdk at en.wikipedia. Permission: CC-BY-SA-3.0.

India continues to deal aggressively with pirates. “The Hindu” reports the actions of the INS Sukanya (1,890 tons full load, 331′ loa) when five skiffs approached vessels in the five ship convoy she was escorting,

“While two of them managed to escape, INS Sukanya successfully intercepted the remaining three boats and…nabbed 26 Somali pirates with six AK 47 rifles, 12 magazines and about 300 rounds of ammunition.

“This is the fifth successful anti-piracy operation conducted by INS Sukanya in the course of her ongoing patrol mission in the Gulf of Aden that commenced in September, the Navy said.”

The uncertainty introduced by the Kenyan invasion of Southern Somalia is having an effect on the ransom pirates are demanding for the ships and crews they currently hold. Ransom demands have been cut as the pirates hope to “close the deal.

There are reports that Ethiopia has also moved troops into Somalia to support the Kenyan invasion.

While Kenya and Ethiopia move against Al Shabaab rebels in the South, there is a report the locals in Puntland are moving against pirates enclaves in the Northeast.

Nigeria/Gulf of Guinea

gCaptain reports three people were kidnapped after eight armed men boarded an offshore supply vessel, the MV C-Endeavour, belonging to Edison Chouest Offshore, off the coast of Nigeria. The report came by email from Kurt Glaubitz, a spokesman for Chevron.

Mekong River:

The attack that left 13 Chinese dead, reported in the last update, has resulted in China dispatching up to 1,000 armed police to work in the territory of Burma, Thailand, and Laos, to protect its trade on the Mekong.

Armed Security Guards:

The Marine Log reports H.R. 2838, the Coast Guard and Maritime Transportation Act of 2011, that recently passed the U.S. House of Representatives, “…strengthens existing authorities against piracy, as well as improves an existing training program to instruct mariners on acceptable use of force against pirates.  It authorizes armed security on vessels carrying government impelled cargo through high risk waters, and includes a report on ways to improve U.S. efforts to track ransom payments and the movement of money through Somali piracy networks.

“‘Somali pirates have vastly expanded the range of their attacks on merchant vessels.  But even more alarming, the pirates have dramatically increased the number and viciousness of their attacks in recent months,’ said LoBiondo (Coast Guard Subcommittee Chairman Frank A. LoBiondo (R-NJ). ‘To protect American seafarers, this legislation will strengthen an existing training program on use of force against pirates.  Additionally, it will provide authority for government agencies to reimburse shippers for armed security aboard vessels carrying U.S. aid to the region.‘”

The Maritime Executive reports there is a growing consensus in the US, that failure to provide armed security may open up ship owners to legal liability for failure to provide seaman with a safe working environment and a seaworthy vessel.

Elsewhere authorities remain unconvinced. The Netherlands is telling its ship owners that, if they use private armed security guards, they could be subject to criminal prosecution.

“Jumbo Shipping from Rotterdam and Vroon Shipping based in Breskens have both said they will carry armed guards while sailing under the Dutch flag.

“The ministry of defence has set up special teams to help combat the threat of piracy but the shipping firms say this is not a solution. ‘You have to order them six weeks in advance and we cannot work like that,’ the Jumbo spokesman said.

“Denmark, Spain, Norway and Britain do allow shipping firms to use private security guards while travelling close to the Somali coast.”

5 thoughts on “Piracy Update, 20 November, 2011

  1. That boat, the INS Sukanya is perfect for the USCG as an OPC. The one thing I like about the INS Sukanya and the Sukanya class patrol vessel, is that they have provisions and capability that can bring them to Light frigate standards if the need arises. Maybe that is something the US Coast Guard should be looking at. Making the NSC and OPC capable of being upgraded to Light Frigate standards if they deploy overseas of if needed in an emergency.

    • As BFayer says, INS Sukanya, is not “perfect.” It does not have the range or speed we would like. It’s twin diesel powerplant is not particularly fuel efficient. It is relatively manpower intensive, although no more so than 210s or 270s. It has less powerful weapons than the 270s or the proposed OPC. Other than the weapons (which can be changed) it could be only a slight improvement over the existing ships, but the idea of being upgradable is a good one. To be quickly upgradable requires something like the mission module concept on the LCS, otherwise upgrades, other than the most basic, will probably take months.

      This class does show how much can be accomplished with a relatively simple ship. The anti-piracy mission certainly does not require the sophistication of a cruiser or destroyer. Apparently the US uses more sophisticated ships because they are going to be in the Indian Ocean anyway, and because the US Navy really does not have any simple combatants with decent endurance.

      • I do like the idea of having a ship that is upgradeable to Light Frigate standards in case we have to deploy overseas or do ARG escort duty. It’s something the US Coast Guard should have explored when they built the NSC and possibly the OPC as well. Have a ship that capable and can be upgraded to Light frigate standards in case of overseas deployment or we as tasked with an Amphibious ready group.

        The INS Sukanya dose demonstrate that a Ship can be upgradeable to light frigate standards in case of emergency. The INS Sukanya has the capability to load up on frigate weapons and systems such as the 57 MM gun, Towed sonar, Torpedo, Sea ram/cwis and possibly Harpoons. It’s something the US Coast Guard should look at as a proof of concept.

  2. Although I respect your opinion, I don’t believe this vessel meets any of our KPPs. I would think to be “perfect” it should meet not only our threshold requirements but also exceed them in most if not all areas. This vessel does not do that.

  3. Pingback: Piracy Update, 21 December, 2011 - CGBlog.org

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s